Just how old does an angler have to be to go ice fishing? If you happen to live in Saskatchewan, there is now a precedent for no minimum age whatsoever. This came about after an incident in March when an ice fisherman, Jack Pick, was ticketed for dipping four lines into Turtle Lake. According to the CBC, regulations only allow an angler two lines at a time, but the man claimed that the extra pair were for his daughter, who was beside him at the time. The conservation officer who ticketed Pick stood by the ticket, claiming that the three-year-old girl was too young to be able to ice fish. Pick then took the ticket to provincial court and won.

“Just because an individual is three years of age, and does not have the ability to do everything required when fishing, it does not mean that he or she cannot legally fish,” Judge Dan O’Hanlon wrote in his ruling.

The Star Pheonix reported that O’Hanlon found nothing in the regulations that required minors to be able to set, maintain, and retrieve fish on their own before being allowed to fish. Just like adults, children are not required to have certain degree of skill or experience before dipping their lines, so O’Hanlon found no reason why the three-year-old should not be able to fish. In Canda, minors under the age of 16 do not have to obtain a fishing license and in Saskatchewan, any fish that children catch do not have to be included in the supervising adult’s quota. In fact, like many agencies elsewhere, Saskatchewan’s Ministry of Environment actively encourages parents to introduce their kids to fishing. So much so that Pick submitted a publication of the agency, the 2014 Saskatchewan Angler’s Guide, as evidence.

The cover of the the publication showed a male angler helping a young girl with the basics of fishing, an interesting parallel to Pick’s own case.

The cover of the 2014 Saskatchewan Anglers' Guide, which was used by Pick in his case. Image courtesy Government of Saskatchewan.
The cover of the 2014 Saskatchewan Anglers’ Guide, which was used by Pick in his case. Image courtesy Government of Saskatchewan.

“It is notable that the cover picture chosen for this publication is of what appears to be a father baiting or tying a hook on the fishing rod and line held by his young daughter,” O’Hanlon said.

Pick was found not guilty of the charge, and the ticket was thrown out.

What do you think? Is it ridiculous to say someone is too young to fish? Feel free to share with us in the comments below.

Featured image courtesy US Fish and Wildlife Service

What's Your Reaction?

Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

9 thoughts on “Canadian Man and His 3-year-old Daughter Win “Too Young to Ice Fish” Case

  1. One of my earliest memories is of my first fishing trip with my parents when I was about three years old. I didn’t tie or bait my hook or even reel in the trout, but I did hold the rod and felt that electric tug of a bite and the power of the fish on the line. Not only was the fish hooked, so was I.

    1. I was 5 for my first trip to my uncles shanty. I remember well, because a month later I received a fishing pole, and little tackle box for X-mas. Fished every year since. That was in lower Mi.

  2. It’s absolutely crazy to consider a
    child being too young to fish. How else is a child going to learn the basics except through the assistance of an experienced adult.

  3. There are hundreds of thousands of gangbangers out that might not be if someone took them out when young and taught them how to fish.

  4. My grandfather took fishing as long as I can remember. So I must have 4 or 5 at the time. This was in Wisconsin in another lifetime for me as I am now 55 and my grandfather has gone to better place, where he does not have to see what has been wrought on us by our government. As far as I can remember, we were never questioned by the Wisconsin DNR personnel or whatever they were called back in the 60’s. Even as a teen, we were never questioned. I guess they are always looking for further fines and fees to further their quest for revenue.

  5. I agree that in a day and age where far too many children (and adults) spend the majority of their time staring at a computer screen or cell phone screen, getting a child outdoors is of utmost importance to the future of conservation. I don’t think, however, that the bag limits for adults shouldn’t apply to children as well since these bag limit numbers are created to protect the fish and game populations. All things said, good for Mr. Pick for fighting the unjust ticket when he knew that he was ultimately doing the right thing by the child.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *